Start your keto weight loss. Uncover your lean, healthy and healed body. Get your complete 60-day keto plan now.
September 17, 2017 by Leanne Vogel July 23, 2018
Interview with Vivica Menegaz, chatting about thyroid health, signs of thyroid deficiency, thyroid labs, plus actionable steps to support your thyroid with supplements and a modified ketogenic diet, and so much more.
Sometimes I come across a wealth of information from a source who is so amazing that I find myself wanting to share that information over and over to reach as many people as possible. That’s exactly what’s going on with today’s guest, who is sharing her wealth of knowledge on all things THYROID. This episode is a MUST listen!
It can be really overwhelming to dive in a topic that varies so much from person to person, but what I love about this interview with Vivica is that she breaks everything down in a way that feels manageable with practical advice that works for everyone. Managing your thyroid health can seem intimidating, but with Vivica’s tips, you can develop a plan and tailor it to fit your personal experience.
In today’s podcast, we’re chatting about what you can do to help support your thyroid, including how to identify thyroid deficiencies. Today’s interview is with Vivica Menegaz, who has made it her mission to help educate people about how to heal the body with nutrient dense foods so that they can transform their health and overall quality of life. This episode is all about how to heal the thyroid by identifying and treating the cause of thyroid imbalance, how to modify a ketogenic diet to best support the thyroid, and what tests and supplements you do (and don’t!) need for optimal thyroid health.
Let’s get to the interview!
For podcast transcript, scroll down.
Thrive Market 35% savings – get an instant 35% off your favorite premium organic products. All you have to do is enter your email address, and the discount will be applied to your cart!
I love starting my day off with a Rocket Fuel Latte, and an RFL just wouldn’t be the same without Manitoba Harvest hemp hearts! Get 15% off your Canadian or US based Manitoba Harvest order with the coupon code KETO, now through December 31, 2017.
100% grass-fed & finished FERMENTED beef sticks with 1 billion naturally-occurring, gut-healing probiotics! Go to Paleovalley.com for an instant 20% off.
Leanne Vogel: You’re listening to Episode Number 51 of The Keto Diet podcast. Today we’re chatting about the importance of thyroid health, signs of thyroid deficiencies, five steps to balancing your thyroid, and so much more, so stay tuned.
Hey, I’m Leanne from HealthfulPursuit.com and this is The Keto Diet Podcast where we’re busting through the restrictive mentality of a traditional ketogenic diet to uncover the life you crave. What’s keto? Keto is a low carb high fat diet where we’re switching from a sugar burning state to becoming fat burning machines.
All listeners of the podcast receive a free seven-day keto meal plan complete with a shopping list and everything you need to chow down on keto for seven whole days. Download your free copy at HealthfulPursuit.com/ketomeal. The link will also be in the show notes for today’s episode. Perfect if your daily keto meals have become a bit lackluster, if you’re new to keto and a bit lost when it comes to eating what and how much, or thrive on being guided on what to do and when to do it. Again, that’s healthfulpursuit.com/ketomeal. Let’s get this party started.
Hey guys, happy Episode 51! I can’t believe we’re celebrating our one year anniversary of The Keto Diet Podcast, this is crazy! Thanks so much for listening. Right now, I am sitting in a closet – yes, a CLOSET! Recording this intro for today’s podcast because we are still on the book tour at this point. Not when the show goes live … I will have been at home for a couple of days after the show goes live, but right now, we are in LA. There’s a couple more hours before our book signing, and I needed to do this intro, so I jumped in the closet. It’s the quietest place I could find that had the lowest amount of echo; I am cushioned between a bunch of cushions and pillows, trying to record this. Apologize in advance if the sound isn’t the best … but that’s what it’s gonna be! The podcast has to keep rolling!
I’ve really, really, really enjoyed the book tour so far. We have just four more spots to go at this point, and I’m very much looking forward to going home, but I’ve also really, really enjoyed meeting each and every one of you. So if you came out to any of the signings, thank you so much! If I missed your city, I’m sorry, I’m hoping to take … a little bit of a break here and perhaps we’ll go back on tour again. Not really sure at this point, but thanks so much for coming out and supporting the book and my work, and just everything. I really enjoyed meeting with you.
The show notes and full transcript for today’s episode can be found at healthfulpursuit.com/podcast/e51. The transcript is added to the post about three to five days following the initial air date of this episode and let’s hear from one of our awesome partners.
My friends at Thrive Market are offering you 35% off your first box of groceries, plus free shipping and a 30-day trial so you can re-order your favorites a couple of weeks down the road. Imagine spending only $9.95 as opposed to the $20.99 on raw cacao powder or $15.65 as opposed to $24.99 on MCT oil if you go to a retail store. On top of their everyday wholesale prices, the extra 35% off your first box of organic and non-GMO products, plus free shipping is going to make a regular $100 grocery run into about a $50, maybe $75 Thrive Market order for the same amount of things. You can go to thrivemarket.com/hp to get your instant 35% off. This offer will expire in a couple of weeks, so if you’re on the fence about it, the time is now. This offer is available to new Thrive Market customers only and people in the US.
If you have an idea for a podcast episode or want to submit praise over and above the review, which you can leave by going to healthfulpursuit.com/review, you can reach me at firstname.lastname@example.org. This is something that I always share with you guys, definitely email me at that email address if you have any questions or an idea for an episode. It’s really, really important also that you take some time to review the show. If you are enjoying the podcast, or even if there’s things that you would like to see changed, please submit a review by going to iTunes, submitting your review, submitting a star rating, and writing a little something. You can also head straight to healthfulpursuit.com/review and it will automatically redirect you to iTunes.
There’s one announcement that I have for you guys today: time is running out for the Back to School sale on my Balanced Keto meal planning subscription program. Balanced Keto is a meal plan, a KETOGENIC meal plan, that you receive once a week on Tuesdays. It gives you all the shopping lists, everything that you need to chow down on keto for a full 7 days. You can head on over to healthfulpursuit.com/balancedketo to get your meal plans for 20% off using the promo code SCHOOL, that’s all in caps, no spaces, before the sale ends on September 20, 2017, so you have just a couple more days to head on over there. The link will also be in the show notes where you can take advantage of that. Again, the coupon code is SCHOOL.
Our guest today, her name is Vivica, she’s a certified technician in whole nutrition with four years of clinical practice. Recently, she opened her own web-based practice specializing in therapeutic ketogenic diets. Vivica is also the creator of The Healing Foods Method, a 10-week course to transform health and lifestyle with a focus on metabolism and endocrine rebalancing. Vivica’s blog, The Nourished Caveman, is filled with delicious keto, paleo recipes with lots of useful information.
We actually recorded this episode quite some time ago, back in September 2015, about two years ago to the day, actually, which is pretty cool. It was for my YouTube channel before I was podcasting, I used to interview people on my YouTube channel. If you haven’t checked out my YouTube channel, definitely do, we’ll include a link in the show notes. This was just such a great episode about your thyroid and what it is that I thought many of you have just followed me on the podcast, maybe you haven’t heard this episode before, and there’s just such great information. I’ve been receiving so many questions about the thyroid that I figured why not use this content and recycle it because it is just THAT good.
So without further ado, I hope you really enjoy it, let’s cut over to it!
Thanks for coming on the show!
Vivica Menegaz: Thanks for having me. It’s so exciting. It’s awesome.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. We’re matching a little bit, like we’re channeling the white.
Vivica Menegaz: I know.
Leanne Vogel: Okay. I did a little bit of introduction and I want to just jump right into it, unless you want to say something before, because we have a lot of questions.
Vivica Menegaz: No. Let’s go ahead. Let’s do it.
Leanne Vogel: Okay. I paneled the Healthful Pursuit readers in our community and they had a bunch of questions. I thought we’d do like a good introduction to the thyroid gland overall. Can you tell us a little bit about what the thyroid is for people that don’t know?
Vivica Menegaz: Okay. The thyroid, it’s located right here, first of all. You can actually feel your own thyroid when you swallow. If you go like this, you’ll feel a little movement inside. (NOTE: if you are able to feel your thyroid cartilage when you swallow, this may be a sign of an enlarged thyroid and you should see a medical professional.)
Leanne Vogel: Dude.
Vivica Menegaz: Like, “Wa-wa.” It goes up and down. That’s a really good thing to locate your thyroid, know where it is, get familiar with it. We call it the master gland because the thyroid is really the main gland of the endocrine system. It’s a regulator. Thyroid hormones have effect on a lot of different bodily functions.
If you look, there is a thing called the Harrower’s chart which is from Dr. Harrower. It’s a chart of endocrine connections. It shows you all the interdependence of the endocrine system. It shows you all the connections between all the different glands and how the suppressors stimulate each other. The thyroid is one of the ones that you really see. It has the most connections and really is tied in in the center of the endocrine system.
Sometimes … I don’t know. I was talking to a patient with this metaphor yesterday. It was really funny. Nutrition is your journey. You start to climb Mt. Everest. Then you’re going up this mountain and you’re working on all the different things on the pillars of nutrition. Digestion, detoxing, blah, blah, blah. Then you reach the top of the mountain, and then sits a golden temple in the shape of a thyroid.
Leanne Vogel: Oh my gosh, that is perfect. Yes.
Vivica Menegaz: Which is good visual, too, like give you the importance of the thyroid in the body.
Leanne Vogel: Yes. It’s so true. So many issues stem from the thyroid imbalance.
Vivica Menegaz: Yes. Although the thyroid sits on top, that means that it really … I’m jumping ahead here a bit, but one of the main issues that we face nowadays is trying to fix the thyroid without fixing everything else it rests upon. The thyroid is really the pinnacle and the controller, but in order for you to function properly, we need to address all the other underlying factors that determine thyroid health.
Leanne Vogel: You’re saying that hypothetically, if somebody has a low thyroid, chances are, if their thyroid is low, there’s a lot of other things going on and you need to fix all those other things before or during the time that you’re fixing your thyroid. Would that be fair to say?
Vivica Menegaz: Yes. Most definitely.
Leanne Vogel: What hormone specifically is the thyroid related to? You hear a lot about the thyroid can impact the adrenals which produces cortisol. How is that connection put together?
Vivica Menegaz: The thyroid itself produces … The main hormones are T4 that then gets converted into T3. Then, also, it’s about 90% T4 production and 10% T3. T3 is the active form of T4. It’s quite complex. Actually, the workings of the thyroid, they are quite complex. I’m still always putting it all together. It’s a really complicated puzzle, but that’s our physiology in the end.
It also produces … There is reverse T3 and then T2. Calcitonin is also produced that affects calcium levels. I hope I’m not saying something wrong here. If you want to look at the relationship with the adrenals and the thyroid, sometimes we call them two hands of the same stick. It’s like you have adrenals and thyroid, and you cannot really move the stick without sending one out of balance. There is this really strong connection.
I like another analogy even better, which is the pyramid. You have adrenals on one corner, and ovaries or gonads on the other corner, and then the thyroid sits on top. In order to achieve the balance, everything has to be stable and solid. Also, it’s a great analogy for a practitioner because it really explains you how you need to start addressing adrenal and sex hormones before you can work with the thyroid directly. You can support the thyroid, but without doing the other work before, it’s really useless.
Leanne Vogel: I always say in my practice with that triangle that you said, it’s like a three-legged stool, and when you kick one leg out, it just falls over.
Vivica Menegaz: That’s a great.
Leanne Vogel: You can’t make it work. That’s another analogy for your practice.
Vivica Menegaz: I like that. “Whoops!”
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. “Whoop!” That’s often what happens. What are the symptoms of thyroid imbalance? How would somebody know, if somebody is watching this … I’m thinking a woman is watching this and thinking, “Okay, so I know what the thyroid is, but how do I know if it’s imbalanced?”
Vivica Menegaz: Well, especially for women, and I would say in my case, very closely related to myself, for women over 40 which are the most likely to start developing thyroid problems, one of the main thing you notice is the weight gain. It starts with really noticing that you’ve gained a bunch of weight and you can’t lose it no matter what you’re doing.
Of course, there is also a metabolic pathway involved in that. I’m big on ketogenic diet because a lot of people have carbohydrate intolerance, and that is involved in that weight gain, but, again, if you go around to the other side, it is related to the thyroid through the carb intolerance as well.
When you’re carb intolerant, then you stress your adrenals because your cortisol has to regulate your sugar levels all the time. You’re constantly putting the stress in the adrenals. Your blood sugar is going up and down like crazy like a roller coaster. That stresses the adrenals, and when the adrenals are stressed, the thyroids start toppling over that stool.
Again, the weight loss is connected in both ways, metabolic pathway, and then directly to hypothyroidism. Then there are things like depression. That’s another really big one. When you’re the blues, the constant blues, not being able to get one, that’s easily solved with some Prozac. Depression is a Prozac deficiency.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah.
Vivica Menegaz: Anyways. Another symptom is cold hands and feet, especially hands and feet, but just this general feeling of being cold and not being able to warm up. Having to like to sit in the sun like a lizard. You’re never sweating. By the way, one little tidbit of information that I learned not recently, when you know certain people don’t sweat …
Leanne Vogel: Yes.
Vivica Menegaz: They’re like, “Why I don’t sweat? I can’t sweat.” Well, guess what? That’s an iodine deficiency.
Leanne Vogel: That’s really interesting that you say that because I started supplementing with iodine about four months ago, like in May, and I was like I sweat, but never crazily. I’d go to hot yoga and maybe I’d get a couple of drips. The last couple of weeks, I am drenched in sweat. Drenched. I was like, “What is going on?” In yoga, in my sauna. Okay.
Vivica Menegaz: That’s fantastic.
Leanne Vogel: Interesting. Interesting.
Vivica Menegaz: Yup. Thank you for reconfirming that.
Leanne Vogel: That is so cool. I couldn’t put the two together, so thank you for confirming it for me. What are the causes of a thyroid imbalance? In know that I’ve heard, especially here in Canada, in our city, we actually got our fluoride taken away from our water. Thank goodness.
Vivica Menegaz: Oh really? They did?
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. They took it out, but I’ve also heard that chloride and bromide, these are the three that affect our thyroid. Are there other things? How did those items take …
Vivica Menegaz: Halogens.
Leanne Vogel: Sorry?
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah. Halogens.
Leanne Vogel: Okay.
Vivica Menegaz: Halogens are directly related to iodine deficiency because what happens when you’re deficient in iodine … The thyroid really needs iodine. Iodine and iodide. It’s basically iodine, in both forms of iodine and iodide, goes into the thyroid and is basically one of the pieces of the T3 and T4 hormones. Without iodine and iodide, T3 and T4 are not created in the thyroid.
We are all really iodine deficient. Especially if you don’t live by the ocean, you’re not eating fish everyday, you don’t eat seaweed, you live inland, your soil is iodine deficient. In America, there is one thing called the goiter belt. It’s this area where everybody has goiters, and that’s because the soil is iodine deficient and it’s inland. By the thyroid being iodine deficient, then it is prone to absorb other halogens just because it’s like, “I really need this, but it’s not available! Okay, this looks almost similar. Let’s put it in.”
Leanne Vogel: Interesting.
Vivica Menegaz: Molecularly, all the halogens are very similar. I think there are just one atomic composition difference, very, very slight difference, but the iodine is the healthy halogen while the chlorine or fluorine, fluoride … Chloride is actually not as bad. For some reason, it seems to be present in nature. It’s not as toxic, but bromide and bromine and fluoride and fluorine and chlorine, those are all really, really toxic.
Leanne Vogel: As a girl who has a hot tub, because she thought it was a good idea when she was a runner, I never go in that thing anymore, but for people that are swimmers or going to the hot tub, you would think that … I take a lot of my medicine and supplements on my skin, so by sitting in a hot tub with all that stuff, that is what you’re … You’re soaking up those things into your skin and into your body. Just a heads up.
Vivica Menegaz: Yup. Absolutely. The good news is that there is a way to prevent this from happening, and that is doing iodine loading. Saturating your body with the iodine it needs, and then once your body is iodine-saturated, you don’t absorb. You don’t need the halogens anymore, so they’ll just bounce off of you pretty much.
Leanne Vogel: Is the test with the two inches of iodine on your skin to see whether or not it soaks in, is that a good test? I’ve read that, but I don’t know.
Vivica Menegaz: No. Unfortunately, what happens is the test is very unreliable because about 60% of the iodine evaporates within the first minute, depending on room temperature. If the room is over, I don’t know, 70 degrees, then most of the iodine just evaporates. You would have to have very clinically controlled environment in order for this to be a reliable test, and that doesn’t happen.
What is really good for iodine test, there are two kind of iodine tests. One is the 24-hour iodine loading test, and it’s done with multiple samples of urine. Then the other one is just a one-sample urine loading test that you do. You got iodine at night, and then you pee in the morning, and they sample it. The other one, they just load you up with, I don’t know, 150 milligrams. Depending on the lab, it’s different. Then they test you within 24 hours. You have to collect urine samples within 24 hours, then put them all together and send them in.
More of my interview with Vivica Menegaz after this message from one of our podcast partners.
The podcast is sponsored by Manitoba Harvest, the hemp-based food company. Hemp hearts are hemp seeds with the shells removed. They’re tender, fatty, zero grams of net carbs, rich in omegas, fiber and protein. Listeners of the podcast can get 15% off your Canadian or U.S. based Manitoba Harvest order by going to HealthfulPursuit.com/hemp and using the coupon code KETO.
Since we’re on the iodine topic, something related to this, I guess to summarize what you’ve said so far is that iodine is the super nutrient for our thyroid. I think that’s fair to say. I started taking iodine, like I said, but over the last, I would say, week, I’ve been getting lower gut pains every time I eat them or have my iodine drops. Do you know why that could be, or if you’ve heard of something like that before? Not to put you on the spot. I was just curious.
Vivica Menegaz: No. Yeah. The first thing that comes to my mind, it can be a detoxing reaction. When you start taking iodine … Iodine is a whole other topic. That’s a huge topic. There is lots of controversy about it, but I love this topic. I’m happy to talk about it. You can start detoxing from halogens at any time.
To really load your body with iodine, it takes about a year to three years. It’s not a quick process. This is doses of like 15 to 50 milligrams, not microgram, milligrams per day, which is also something that for people with Hashimoto’s would not be recommended. I would do it in a very different way.
Let’s say you don’t have Hashimoto’s and you just have thyroid issues, primary hypothyroidism, and you want to do iodine loading. Keep in mind, if you don’t do it with a practitioner, that at any point in time, you can start getting into a pocket of toxicity as your glands and your tissues saturate. Your iodine is stored in the thyroid, it’s stored in the breast tissue mostly, and it’s stored in the skin, too, at some level. A bit less. For example, there has been cases of people that after three, four months started oozing bright yellow stuff out of their breasts.
Leanne Vogel: I’d freak out.
Vivica Menegaz: That’s fluoride, fluorine coming out from the breast tissue. In fact, that’s one of the reasons why iodine is one of the most amazing cancer preventative because you will keep that breast tissue saturated and healthy so that nothing bad will go in there. Also, it’s really protective for the cells. It enables the cells to work at the best efficiency level, so that is great prevention.
Leanne Vogel: Okay. What you’re saying is put some more iodine in my water tomorrow and just … Yeah, it was just weird. Lower gut pain, and I’m like, “What is going on?”
Vivica Menegaz: I wouldn’t add more.
Leanne Vogel: No, I stopped taking it a couple of days ago because I was like, “This is brutal, so get back to doing that.”
Vivica Menegaz: Maybe pull your dose in half.
Leanne Vogel: Okay. Good to know.
Vivica Menegaz: Whenever that happens, I would go back to those and just take it easy, but go steady because you need to come through that detox part …
Leanne Vogel: Interesting.
Vivica Menegaz: … So that you can clean up and load and then keep going.
Leanne Vogel: I had no idea. Okay, that makes sense. Now getting to low carb diets and ketogenic, because we’re both keto girls, are there risks to doing a ketogenic eating style and your thyroid? You hear a lot about ketogenic eating styles maybe not being so good for the thyroid, or eating low carb, keto not being good for the thyroid. Can you talk a little bit about your experience with that?
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah. First of all, I really don’t think it is true, but then again, we need to do a bunch of consideration about that statement. I don’t work with just random ketogenic diets. I work with the therapeutic ketogenic diets. That means that I work with elimination diet as well. My ketogenic diet is paleo mostly. I would say 90% paleo.
I check and test for allergens and sensitivities. That connects me back to the staples, the pillars that support the thyroid, because one of those pillars is gut health and digestion. For example, if you have sensitivities that … Dairy, for example. Pork. Eggs. It could be anything. Grains, not really because we don’t do that on keto, so it is one last thing to worry about.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. True.
Vivica Menegaz: When you have a leaky gut and you have that dairy protein leaking in, it starts a whole chain reaction. You will not be able to absorb the right nutrients that the thyroid needs when your gut is not functioning, and your upper digestion also, not enough HCl, so the whole digestive system and the balance of digestion is really related to thyroid health. It’s one of the basis. If you’re not doing a therapeutic diet, just a random ketogenic diet where you say, “Okay, I’m going to McDonald’s but I’m eating keto macros” … which is possible.
Leanne Vogel: Totally.
Vivica Menegaz: Some people do it.
Leanne Vogel: Yes. I have met those people.
Vivica Menegaz: Right. That, it wouldn’t be good for the thyroid for sure, but as far as just if we just talked about a clean therapeutic ketogenic diet and the carb restriction, I have to say that women have different carb needs than men, and especially women of a certain age. When you’re 20, it’s very different than when you’re 40 or 50 or 60. For women, I feel that what works the best … Remember, we talked about it in our first chats, private chats before …
Leanne Vogel: Yeah, we did.
Vivica Menegaz: … About ideal carb levels. I find more and more that what I do, I use a very low level of carbs for keto adaption, like 20 grams, but once we are properly keto-adapted, then I tend to raise them depending on the situation and the metabolism. If you’re a woman, and let’s say a woman over 30, unless your problem is strictly metabolic, and let’s say you have diabetes but your adrenals are fine, your thyroid is fine, endocrine system seems to work fine, it’s possible. Not common, but possible.
Leanne Vogel: I’ve never met with anyone who has that profile. One?
Vivica Menegaz: Yes.
Leanne Vogel: Wow. That’s amazing.
Vivica Menegaz: She’s Canadian, by the way.
Leanne Vogel: Yes. Yup. Represent.
Vivica Menegaz: Unless it’s that very rare and specific situation where I would say, “Okay, pancreas is our main focus, carb intolerance, super high, insulin resistance, super high,” then we need to keep the carbs really low and controlled, but otherwise, I think that it is healthier to try to bring up the carbs to the sensitivity level, so where we can do the highest level of carbs for your tolerance. It might be 50 grams a day, it might be 60, it might be 90 for some people.
You can reset a lot of your insulin resistance by doing strictly low carb, keto, and there are a lot of techniques for that specifically, but once you’re now so insulin-resistant and you start to be insulin-sensitive, then you can have more carbs. Of course, good carbs. Lately, I’ve been prescribing my patients my new recipe for keto bagels, and they’re just super fiber. They’re called the “Colon Cleanser”.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. Get things moving.
Vivica Menegaz: Super high fiber. They’re very high fiber, and mostly higher carbs are what irregular keto food would be, but they are really good carb. When you’re in keto, you need that fiber desperately, so it seems like one of the little tricks that I use to raise carbs without having them fall into things like potatoes or rice. Don’t do rice.
Leanne Vogel: Even white rice? You would say, “Don’t do white rice”?
Vivica Menegaz: I prefer not.
Leanne Vogel: Okay. Yeah.
Vivica Menegaz: It might just be a personal stigma, but white rice doesn’t have a lot of nutrition.
Leanne Vogel: No, I totally agree. The only reason I don’t eat rice is because I can’t stop eating rice. It’s like an empty … It makes me want more rice and rice and rice.
Vivica Menegaz: It’s sugar.
Leanne Vogel: I have some clients that they enjoy having white rice, but it’s like, yeah, at the end of the day, you’re not really filling up your plate. There’s not a lot of nutrients there.
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah. That’s why for fiber … Not fiber, but carb and fiber together, which is fiber is part of the carbs, but I like to use things more like seeds that are nutritious. Usually, they’re quite neutral in a way, so they seem … Although, in my patient, I see over and over that not everybody is sensitive to the same things.
Some people will do great with psyllium or will do great with chia, and they will do horrible with flaxseeds, and some people, it’s the opposite. It’s really like you see over and over that you can’t make a general statement when it comes to diet and what works for your body individually. You have to really play in and see what works for you.
Leanne Vogel: Totally. I love that you mentioned that carb depletion and then increasing carbs. In fact, with my new book, Fat Fueled, I have three different profiles that I’ve done for people, saying, “Do this,” but then, yeah, find that tolerance and go as high as you can go because you will become more sensitive, and then it makes it a lot easier.
Vivica Menegaz: Yes.
Leanne Vogel: I would fall asleep at anything over 80 grams of carbs. I would eat carbs and then just pass out. Now, I can do 80 grams of carbs, no problem, and it’s no big deal, so it’s amazing to see how your body changes with time. Is it fair to say that there are some hormones that the thyroid is responsible that need carbohydrates in order to convert?
Vivica Menegaz: I’m not sure. Honestly, for the kind of endocrinology that I do, which is functional endocrinology, I have never seen a direct correlation between…
Leanne Vogel: Okay. Okay.
Vivica Menegaz: It’s not talked about. I don’t know. I know there is a lot of talk of that out there and also in functional medicine, but with the kind of nutrition I do, it’s a little bit different because it’s … I don’t know what you would even call it. It’s like foundational nutrition. We only use whole food supplements. I don’t use the isolates like the functional medicine doctors do.
We’re a little bit on two different steps. Sometimes there are … For example, the iodine, that’s a big discrepancy because functional medicine doctors tell you, “No iodine at all for Hashimoto’s,” and I use iodine for Hashimoto’s. I use it very, very carefully and in small dosages, but, yes, I do. Same with the carbs. It’s different opinions on different things.
Leanne Vogel: It’s so true. At the end of the day, you just have to try some things, and if you don’t feel good, then you know that that’s not working, and how do you shift that. That’s why we’re both here, that’s why we do what we do, because sometimes when you’re in the heat of it, it’s hard to determine what you need to do personally.
To have a coach or something, being like, “Okay, well, have you tried this and that? I saw this with this other client. Have you tried this,” it brings a lot more into perspective. I know, even for myself, I have a coach because sometimes I’m just like, “I don’t even know what is making me do this,” because you’re right in the heat of it.
Vivica Menegaz: Absolutely.
Leanne Vogel: For people that are listening, women especially that are listening, that know that they have a thyroid condition, maybe they have hypothyroid or Hashimoto’s, if they wanted to try a ketogenic, and our approach, which I believe that my approach, too, is very therapeutic like yours, if we wanted to go toward a ketogenic eating style, like you mentioned before, I guess it’s just like, “Do the therapeutic kind if you know that you have a thyroid imbalance or any imbalance with your health.” Do more of a therapeutic form of ketogenic eating as opposed to the sausages with the eggs, and conventional eggs with the cheese and the sour cream on your plate.
Vivica Menegaz: Exactly. Right.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. Is that fair?
Vivica Menegaz: I’m so glad that you share my same point of view.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. Otherwise, I don’t think … I love having people on the show to talk about health and stuff, and I love when we don’t agree with things, but I also want to make sure that I’m responsible for sharing this information with people. I want to make sure my guests aren’t saying, “Yeah, totally, it’s fine to have conventional meat,” because I don’t think that that’s responsible of me to have a guest on there that just I can’t agree with the recommendations that they’re giving.
Vivica Menegaz: I know.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah, I’m happy that we agree on that. In your introduction, we mentioned that you focus on rebalancing endocrine systems. What are five steps that listeners or watchers could do right now to balance out their thyroid? Maybe they’re interested in ketogenic eating style. Maybe they’re already doing it. Are there a couple of steps that you would recommend doing?
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah. It’s the steps that I use in my practice to achieve that. I’ve got to tell you, it’s not always easy to do it by yourself, but if you’re up for it, go for it. You can always try.
Leanne Vogel: Then if you fail, call us.
Vivica Menegaz: Exactly. We’re still here, right?
Leanne Vogel: Yeah.
Vivica Menegaz: Leanne and Vivica will help you.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah.
Vivica Menegaz: I would definitely start from cleaning up your act. Cleaning up your diet, eliminating possible food sensitivities. Going dairy-free sometimes really helps. Eggs and pork I eliminate when I do a detox phase, but you really could try to be as clean as possible, definitely eliminating toxins.
I always do a detox on my patients when they start my program. Even if they don’t do the program, I do individual consults, I try to make them do a detox because it’s the basis for nutrition. Cleaning out, avoiding allergens, and supporting your liver, that’s all one step for me.
Then step two would be digestion, of course, and making sure that your digestion is working. Upper digestion, maybe HCl supplements that can help you break down that protein. That is what it was going through. It will digest for you. It’s not ideal. There is other things that are better when you get into really fine-tuning digestion, but at least that will do the job so that you don’t get partially digested protein through you digestive system, which is really bad.
Then, of course, lower digestion, probiotics, and eating a good … Fermented foods are great. Cultivate the microbiota. Digestion is second. Adrenal health is third. We know how important that is.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. My smile curled up when you said that. Yes.
Vivica Menegaz: Those adrenals.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah, yeah.
Vivica Menegaz: It’s like the woe of our generation or our time because we’re all way too stressed and we’re too busy and way too many demands on our time and on ourselves. Adrenals, meaning stress management and adrenal support. Yes, people, adrenal fatigue does exist. Come on. Get real.
Leanne Vogel: Right? How could you not think that it doesn’t?
Vivica Menegaz: Because conventional endocrinology, I’m sorry I’m going to say this, forgive me all out there, but it’s in the middle ages. It’s in the dark ages. Really, conventional endocrinology is like has a blinder on. Anyways. That’s adrenal support. Then I would do definitely gonads, meaning sex hormone support. Make sure that your sex hormones are balanced. That’s a very other tricky …
See? That’s what I tell you. Working with the thyroid, it’s not easy. It’s a complicated picture. You really do have to address all these pieces of the puzzle. That is one, and again, I do just … It’s called restorative endocrinology or functional endocrinology, but I just work with rebalancing naturally the hormones.
I don’t use bioidenticals, not even the safest drop sublinguals. I don’t use any of that. I try to do it naturally, but I use herbal supplements and whole food supplements. If that is hard to do by yourself, unless you really know what you’re doing, I would suggest working with a practitioner.
Saliva tests are great for that. Also, saliva test is great for the adrenals. There is one called the adrenal stress index. The ASI test. That’s a great one to see your cortisol pattern so you can have a better idea. By the way, there are websites in the United States where you can order those tests yourself.
Leanne Vogel: That’s amazing.
Vivica Menegaz: You might not know how to read it, but you don’t even need to go and beg your doctors. Doctors are being such pains.
Leanne Vogel: So many of my clients are just … I give them a list of blood work to get and their doctor is like, “No, you don’t need this.”
Vivica Menegaz: Right?
Leanne Vogel: It’s obvious that they have a thyroid issue. We just want to know where’s our thyroid at, what is our cortisol level, what are their adrenals doing, what are their sex hormones … The stool, just to see, the three-legged stool, what’s going on. They’re like, “No, you don’t need that,” and it’s like, “Are you kidding me?”
Vivica Menegaz: No. Then you bang your head against the wall.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. It’s unfortunate because then a lot of people will say, “Oh, well, my doctor said that it’s not a problem.” Well, find a new doctor, really. Just, it’s your body, it’s your health, and at the end of the day, they’re not responsible, really, for how you feel. You are. If you don’t feel good, you got to do something about it. It’s awesome that they have those tests in the US.
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah.
Leanne Vogel: Now it just needs to come up north to Canada.
Vivica Menegaz: I think you can order them for Canada.
Leanne Vogel: Really? Okay, I’ll have to …
Vivica Menegaz: I can send you a link for a site that you can just order tests privately. They have international locations. I know they have in Europe, so maybe also for Canada. I’ll send you a link.
Leanne Vogel: Cool. I will add that to the show notes below so that everyone can check it out if it’s something that resonates with them. I chatted with my community and I have a bunch of rapid-fire questions for both of us. If you can’t answer, I’ll answer it. If I can’t answer, you answer.
Vivica Menegaz: Wait, we forgot, real quick, the last thing. The fifth step.
Leanne Vogel: Oh my gosh! I thought you did five. Do it.
Vivica Menegaz: That’s fast, but thyroid support. Duh.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah, of course.
Vivica Menegaz: The nutrients that the thyroid need which are vitamin C, vitamin D, iron, and, of course, iodine. All the good stuff that the thyroid need to function, and protein, because without thyroglobulin, nothing gets made. If you can’t break down that protein in your stomach and your thyroid doesn’t get the protein to make the hormones, then you don’t have the raw materials.
Leanne Vogel: That goes back up to digestive health because if you don’t have the hydrochloric acid, you’re not breaking down the protein, and it’s like a whole mesh.
Vivica Menegaz: Exactly. Yup.
Leanne Vogel: Like untangling spaghetti.
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah. White spaghetti.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. Take one piece at a time. Okay, yeah. Thanks for the five steps. Geez. Okay, rapid-fire questions.
Vivica Menegaz: Let’s go.
Leanne Vogel: If you have a history of thyroid imbalance in your family, how do you best support your thyroid? Are there changes to steps above that you just mentioned, or do these steps change when you have an autoimmune condition of the thyroid?
Vivica Menegaz: With autoimmune, it’s a little bit of a different ballgame because you have to consider and factor in the autoimmune component first. You do support your body in general. You have to still do all the work that we talked about, but you have to work with also immune regulation. I’m not saying immune suppression here because that is just middle ages. I’m sorry. It’s called immune regulation. Just to make sure you support and regulate your immune system.
For example, there is a lot of controversy, again, about Echinacea. There is this big talk about functional doctors say, “Oh, it’s a Th1 pathway dominant or a Th2 pathway dominant, and if you’re Th2 pathway dominant, Echinacea is bad for you,” but, no, it’s not true because from herbalists, in thousands of years of use of this herb, we know that, and I’m not an herbalist but I use it, Echinacea is an immune regulator. That means it does support whichever part the immune system needs, and that includes both pathways. Just a tidbit there. When you work with Hashimoto’s, you have to seriously consider a bunch of other issues.
I would say, if it’s in your family … Another big talk these days is genetics. Everybody wants to have all these fancy genetic tests done, and then they’re like, “Oh my goodness, I have this gene! Let’s have my boobs cut off!” That is pretty insane to me because, you guys, remember, there is such a thing called gene expression. That comes from epigenetics, which is a great new branch of studying that I love. I recommend everybody to get into epigenetics.
It has a lot of answers, but one of the main thing that epigenetics tells us is that genes do not necessarily express. For example, in the case of thyroid or related to iodine, in the family, you might have bad genetics when it comes to predisposition, but that does not necessarily mean you are going to get the same issues as your mother or your grandmother because you can just use nutrition to modulate.
Again, figure your body and with proper nutrition just make so that the DNA never needs to express certain genes versus others. One word: You’re healthy. You’re not getting sick because you’re healthy, you’re well-nourished, you’re balanced, you’re eating well, you’re keeping everything in check. As far as genetics, it’s nutrition prevention. Nutrition is prevention.
Leanne Vogel: Totally. Amazing.
More of my interview with Vivica Menegaz after this message from one of our podcast partners.
The show is partnered up with Paleovalley, the makers of the only 100% grass-fed and finished fermented beef stick. Each stick contains 1 billion probiotic CFUs. Their gut-friendly sticks are gluten-free, soy-free, dairy-free, GMO-free, freaky chemical additive, dye, and preservative free, as well as being 100% free from carbs and sugar, and made with the highest quality ingredients. Exclusive to listeners of this show receive instant savings of 20% off Paleovalley fermented beef stick snacks by going to Paleovalley.com/keto.
The next question is, is it possible to go too low carb, keto for too long? What effect does that have on our thyroid and our adrenals and our sex hormones? We touched on this, but I want to drive that home so I added that question again from another reader.
Vivica Menegaz: I just think that in general, for women metabolic systems and endocrine systems, that going very, very low carb for a long time is just not appropriate for our body. Honestly, what is the exact physiological pathways of expression of that, maybe I cannot tell you, but I’ve seen it and I’ve experienced it.
I just learned it from clinical practice. Seeing how you were really … It’s so much better to find your individual tolerance level and work with that instead of just ballpark like, “20 grams. Everybody, stay under 20 grams.” That doesn’t work. For men, men have a very much simpler hormonal profile.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. I’m just sighing because my husband, it’s so simple for him.
Vivica Menegaz: Men are, in general, something … I don’t know. How did that happen?
Leanne Vogel: I love being a woman and I wouldn’t trade it for the world, so, just saying that.
Vivica Menegaz: I know, but everything is a lot simpler for a guy.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah.
Vivica Menegaz: For our hormonal picture, I really think that it’s much more delicate and individual. I really think that it’s better for us to work on individual basis. That said, no, I don’t think it’s a good idea to go low carb for too low and too long.
Leanne Vogel: Amen. Thyroid medications. There’s a bunch of questions on thyroid medications from my community. What are the types of options? If you are a low thyroid and it’s quite low and your doctor says you need to go on thyroid medication, what are the types of options, and what’s the best and worst option?
Vivica Menegaz: Okay. I will say in general that thyroid medication has a place. That place is where the patient is so symptomatic that you can’t function. It does bring relief and it’s something that it can be used for a short period of time to really bring up the symptoms and start feeding the thyroid or supplying the hormones until the thyroid restores and rebalances, which is not always a quick process. It might take months, it might take a year, or it might take even longer.
That, I feel like it’s the right place for thyroid medicine. There are some kind of medications that I really do not agree with, and this is the synthetics. When you learn functional endocrinology, you understand that hormones are very powerful and very delicate. When your gland is producing that hormone, we call it upstream, and then it produces these hormones that goes downstream into a process of the body.
You start introducing this hormone downstream, so you’re bringing in a whole bunch of, let’s say, T3 or T4 for the thyroid. What happens to the thyroid? What kind of signal does it get? There is two mechanisms involved. One is the negative feedback, and the other one is also resistance.
First of all, when you keep flooding the gland or your system with hormones, it’s like banging on something. Banging on your finger with a hammer. Your hammer will develop a callous eventually. It’s going to get all thickened, damaged, and it’s not going to even feel anything anymore. Or like if you keep screaming in somebody’s ear, they’re going to get deaf eventually.
That’s the process of becoming resistant to a hormone. When hormones are not strictly regulated … The synthetic hormones are really not even recognized by the body so well. The cells become resistant, first of all, which creates this bad, really catch-22 situation where you need to produce more and more. With insulin, it’s the typical example, that you become insulin resistant, and I’m sure everybody has heard of that, but guess what? It happens with our hormones. Every single one of them. T3 and T4, especially, too.
That works on that level on the synthetic hormones, and it also starts shutting down your thyroid because the thyroid keeps getting this negative feedback, “You don’t need to make hormones. There is plenty around,” so it sits there and waits and waits and waits, and finally goes to sleep. Then once it goes to sleep, it starts maybe dying. It’s like, “Nobody needs me around here. What am I here for?”
Leanne Vogel: A little shriveled up little raisin.
Vivica Menegaz: It’s an existential.
Leanne Vogel: Amazing.
Vivica Menegaz: It’s just like your thyroid decides to leave you and become a monk and go move to Tibet.
Leanne Vogel: Amazing, and it doesn’t become the shrine at the top of Everest.
Vivica Menegaz: I think eventually, that’s what happens. Every little thyroid monk built himself a shrine.
Leanne Vogel: You’re amazing. That’s great. As you can see, we have a lot of fun talking together.
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah, it’s a bit of a dry subject.
Leanne Vogel: So we’ll add monks and Everest. Yeah, I love it. I totally love it.
Vivica Menegaz: It needs to be made entertaining. Yeah, as far as the medication, I will say, if possible, stay away from the synthetics. Armour is the better option. It’s just whole desiccated porcine thyroid. It goes in and brings both the hormones, but it also brings some of the nutrition because it’s whole thyroid gland.
It has iodine in it, it has vitamin C in it, and it has some minerals in it. By the way, there is selenium that’s extremely important. There is iron that’s extremely important. We didn’t even talk about anemia. Well, it’s a complicated subject. Yeah, so what I would do is if your doctor really insists and you’re very symptomatic, then maybe start with a whole desiccated and try to avoid being put on any of these T3, T4 synthetic replacements, which I don’t …
Leanne Vogel: I totally agree.
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah. They don’t heal your thyroid. They just do bad to the thyroid itself.
Leanne Vogel: It’s just patchwork, and then another hole blows out from your boat, and then you have to deal with that which gets patched up. I agree. One thing actually that a lot of my clients has started doing, as well as myself, is you put the thyroid underneath your tongue, the thyroid medication underneath your tongue, and then you let it dissolve until there’s nothing left. Is that something that you’ve worked with before?
Vivica Menegaz: It just makes me think of neurolingual response because we have nervous terminals in the tongue that goes straight to the brain, so they’re really closely connected. They go from here just to your brain. They communicate to the brain about what substance they’re touching, so they’re preparing the body for whatever is coming in. It works …
We do, for example, muscle testing. A lot of times, it’s done with that because your body is already prepping for what is coming in, so you can just test something. I do, for example, the Coca Pulse Test for allergies. Our sensitivities, we do just put in stuff on the tongue. Sometimes, you don’t even have to swallow it and it will start raising your heart. I feel like, yeah, there is a lot of sense to that, and it will start working because your body is already like, “Hey, we got stuff coming in.”
Leanne Vogel: “This is happening.”
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah. That’s true.
Leanne Vogel: Okay, cool. Okay, and thyroid medications, too, are there interactions with them? I know, for instance, you shouldn’t be taking calcium or iron or digestive things like antacids and stuff while you are taking thyroid medication, or within I think it’s like four hours or two hours of your medication? Are there foods that you shouldn’t be eating?
Vivica Menegaz: I’m sorry I’m not sure because I don’t work with the medication unless my patients are on them.
Leanne Vogel: Okay. I can totally answer this question.
Vivica Menegaz: You probably know a ton more about that.
Leanne Vogel: That’s fine. Cabbage. Collards. Fenugreek is one, especially if you’re a breastfeeding mom and you’re on thyroid … fenugreek because you’re probably on fenugreek then. Flax is one. There’s also kale. St John’s wort and kelp. Kelp, yeah, which is interesting.
Vivica Menegaz: It has iodine.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah, yeah, so don’t take kelp or iodine too close to your thyroid medication because it could throw off your pills usually, but if you have it dissolved underneath your tongue, it’s going to hit your body a lot quicker. Usually, it’s about like an hour or two, and then you can have all of those things, and rotate it, too. I wouldn’t sit down and have a huge bowl of cabbage for breakfast. I have done that, so that is why I say that.
We talked about the side effects of thyroid medications, like if you do the synthetic Synthroid type thing, it’s going to cause a lot more issues. If you’re taking too high a dose of thyroid medications, your metabolism can get a little bit wonky and all that.
How do you know when your thyroid meds are working? A good way I know, take your temperature is a good one.
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah. That’s a good one, yes.
Leanne Vogel: Track your temperature before you even move in the morning or right before bed. I keep a thermometer underneath my pillow and I literally turn over very slowly, grab it, and stick it in my mouth. I’ve tried underneath my armpit, but I don’t get an accurate reading underneath my armpit.
Vivica Menegaz: No. I do under the tongue also. It’s much better, yes.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. I always do the same side so it’s as accurate as possible. Same time, I wake up at the same time every day, test then, and then before I go to bed.
Vivica Menegaz: Yeah, and chart it.
Leanne Vogel: Yes.
Vivica Menegaz: What I have my patients do, I do a little bit different temperature test because I do another test that averages temperatures. It shows you both adrenal and thyroid function, but, yeah, it’s great to chart it because then you start seeing how it goes up and down, and where it is, and how it flattens out. Yeah, that’s a great tip.
Leanne Vogel: Awesome. Last question is goitrogens. Are they real? Is it actually a thing?
Vivica Menegaz: Yes, they are real.
Leanne Vogel: Okay.
Vivica Menegaz: There are such things as goitrogen foods, but I got to say this, that even if you have thyroid issues, it’s okay to eat your kale and your cabbage. You just have to not go crazy on it. My indication is one to maximum two portions a day of any goitrogen food. If you want to eat cabbage or broccoli or Brussels sprouts, and I don’t remember all of them, but no more than two portions a day.
Leanne Vogel: Do they get inactive or lessen impact when they’re cooked?
Vivica Menegaz: Yes. Definitely.
Leanne Vogel: Okay.
Vivica Menegaz: It’s better to have them cooked when you do have thyroid issues, but if you have like one arugula salad a week, you’re not going to tip it overboard. Especially if you are doing all the good nutrition and you’re taking your iodine and all the vitamins and minerals and everything else we talked about, then the goitrogen is really minimally impacting.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah. Totally.
Vivica Menegaz: Taken in perspective.
Leanne Vogel: That’s amazing. Well, those are all the questions that I had.
Vivica Menegaz: Wow.
Leanne Vogel: Oh my gosh, I feel like we aced the thyroid topic, right?
Vivica Menegaz: We scratched the thyroid topic.
Leanne Vogel: Yeah, scratched the total surface, like one grain of sand on a huge beach, but for people that want to know more information about thyroid, and especially when it comes to low carbohydrate. I love that we talked about the fact that too low carb for too long for women I don’t feel is a good idea.
I did that because I was silly and thought, “If I just push harder, it will do a bunch of awesome things,” but it did a bunch of not-so-awesome things. Thankfully, I caught it soon enough, but I have been working with clients who have been 20 … Not even. 10 to 15 grams of carbohydrates for six months.
Vivica Menegaz: Ouch.
Leanne Vogel: Then just a whole world of issues. I hope that the information that we shared … Thank you so much, Vivica. Oh my gosh, you know so much about this topic, so I’m so happy that we had you on the show.
Vivica Menegaz: I feel like I just scratched the surface and we still have books and courses and things that need to be done, but it’s constant learning, so it’s alright.
Leanne Vogel: Totally. For those just looking to heal their bodies, I feel like we gave a lot of good information to people that are just like, “I just need help.” That’s really where it comes from because I’m sure something that you said will spark something in someone and they’ll go searching off.
That’s really what it’s all about. That’s why we do this, is so that people can really put their health into their own hands and get balanced and awesome. I’ll include all of your links below this video, back on my blog, below the YouTube videos. You guys can check it out and go visit and say hello. Thank you so much for being on the show. We will chat soon.
Vivica Menegaz: Thank you so much, Leanne.
Leanne Vogel: Bye.
Vivica Menegaz: Bye-bye.
Leanne Vogel: The show notes, links to more information from Vivica, additional resources, and full transcript for today’s episode can be found at healthfulpursuit.com/podcast/e51. The transcript is added to the post about 3-5 days following the initial air date of this episode.
That does it for another episode of The Keto Diet Podcast. Thanks for listening in. You can follow me on Instagram by searching Healthful Pursuit where you’ll find daily keto eats and other fun things. Check out all my keto supportive programs, bundles, guides and other cool things over at HealthfulPursuit.com/shop, and I’ll see you next Sunday. Bye!
I work on finding the best products that have quality ingredients, care about their customers, and have integrity. The brand(s) I’ve shared here are awesome, and I stand behind them 100%. Opinions in this blog post are never ever influenced by the partner. Like, never!
HI! I’M LEANNE
Nutrition educator + keto enthusiast. I want to live in a world where every woman loves her body, nourishing fats are enjoyed at every meal, and the word “restriction” isn’t in the dictionary.